Look, we know you’re getting a lot of requests for donations this time of year. I wouldn’t blame you for getting overwhelmed and looking for ways to cut down on all the demands. Here’s an easy one: When you donate to help Votebeat get to our $8,000 goal, we’ll opt you out of fundraising emails for the rest of the year. Plus, you’ll be considered a member for the next 365 days, giving you access to our members-only events (like our post-midterms debrief) and more member perks we’ve got in the works. Give any amount today to take advantage and get peace of mind.
Here’s a look at what’s in this edition:
Alaska’s dueling Dans problem fizzles
Confidence in elections rebounds, with a partisan edge
Redistricting wars still aided Republicans, even with a blue wave
And, you won’t see this newsletter next week due to the Thanksgiving holiday. You’ll get the next edition on Dec. 5. Happy Thanksgiving!
Elections don’t end on Election Day. All year long, Votebeat is reporting on the decisions, lawsuits, and policy changes that affect how you vote. Donate any amount to keep this work free for everyone.
The final U.S. Senate contest has finally been called. Democrat Mary Peltola of Alaska became the sixth Democrat to unseat a Republican incumbent in the Senate in this election.
But that’s not the end of the story.
Alaska unexpectedly catapulted to the forefront of the political debate in the waning days of the campaign. That’s when President Donald Trump directed the U.S. Department of Justice to launch an investigation into the state’s Senate race over allegations that a candidate with the same name as the GOP incumbent was trying to confuse voters and pull support from the sitting senator. At the president’s direction, the Justice Department launched criminal and civil investigations, which Attorney General Todd Blanche vowed to pursue regardless of the race’s outcome.
The episode also put a spotlight on how Alaska conducts its elections. Alaska uses ranked choice voting to choose congressional representatives, and conducts open nonpartisan primaries from which four candidates advance to the general election regardless of their party affiliation.
Advocates for those methods say they promote a broader array of choices and more bipartisan outcomes, but critics say they confuse voters. Nonetheless, Alaska’s voters rejected a ballot measure — the second in two election cycles — that would have changed their system.
Alaskans narrowly approved ranked choice voting in 2020 and then rejected a proposal in 2024 to rescind the system, also by a small margin. This year, Alaska voters by a larger margin — 54% to 46% — opted again to keep ranked choice voting and open primaries.
“Yet again, Alaskans have proven that they want to have ranked choice voting and that they like it,” said Amy Lauren Lovecraft, a political science professor at the University of Alaska Fairbanks.
Lovecraft is a supporter of the system, which she says gives Alaskans a chance to break free of the two-party system that dominates American politics.
“If voters would like to have greater control over who runs in general elections and greater control over the ways in which issues are presented to citizens,” then ranked choice voting, as in Alaska, “makes a lot of sense,” Lovecraft said.
But critics of ranked choice voting say that this year’s Senate race is a case study in why the system should be scrapped.
The process encouraged political operatives to try and game the election by secretly supporting a spoiler candidate to confuse voters and drain support from their opponents, critics argued during the ballot measure debate in Alaska.
Alaska allows voters to rank candidates by preference. If no candidate gets more than 50% of first-choice votes, the candidate with the fewest votes is eliminated, and their votes are redistributed based on the voters’ second choices. The process continues until one candidate gets a majority.
At the end of the counting, it turned out that ranked choice voting didn’t come into play. Peltola won more than 50% of the votes. Dan S. Sullivan, the two-term GOP senator, secured 46%. The latest results show Peltola topping Sullivan by more than 12,000 votes.
The other two candidates on the ballot, retired teacher Dan J. Sullivan, who ran without party affiliation, and Republican Gerald Heikes, got fewer than 11,000 combined votes. So even if all those votes eventually ended up with the incumbent, he wouldn’t have won, and having a second candidate with the same name on the ballot ultimately didn’t matter to the outcome.
Even if the state had gone to a ranked choice tabulation, many of the second-place votes for Dan J. Sullivan were destined for Peltola. (One analysis found that less than a quarter of those who chose Dan J. Sullivan as their first choice chose the incumbent as their second choice.)
"Ranked choice voting did not impact the outcome of the 2026 Alaska Senate election,” said Michael Thorning, director of structural democracy at the Bipartisan Policy Center. “While many observers raised concerns about alleged spoiler candidates, ranked choice voting is actually a system that better accounts for those kinds of tactics because it reduces the likelihood of casting a ballot for the wrong party or individual."
What happens next?
In the waning days of the campaign, the New York Times linked Peltola aides to an effort to recruit the retired schoolteacher to join the race in hopes of fracturing the Republican vote by putting another candidate on the ballot with the same name as the incumbent. Peltola has denied involvement in the effort.
Trump repeatedly accused Democrats of using tricks to deceive voters. Wall Street Journal columnist Kim Strassel bashed Alaska for having a “nightmarish electoral system.”
Right before Election Day, the Justice Department sent at least 20 letters to people telling them to preserve documents or that they might be targets in its investigation into the role Democrats played in recruiting the second Dan Sullivan.
While a wide spectrum of legal scholars doubt that the Justice Department could find a crime to successfully prosecute, that doesn’t mean the federal government will drop its investigation. Even before the race was decided, Attorney General Todd Blanche said “the priority of investigating a criminal potential fraud doesn’t stop because of the election, no matter who wins or loses.”
The Justice Department told Votebeat this week that it still plans to pursue the case. On Thursday, the Trump administration dropped a separate legal challenge to try and block certification of the Senate race.
In a legal brief opposing the Trump administration’s attempts to block certification of the Alaska Senate race, Stephen Richer, a Republican who oversaw elections in Arizona's largest county and is now a fellow at the libertarian Cato Institute, argued that it's up to voters to weigh in on any dirty tricks used in the campaign.
"Voters rather than judges must decide when one side has gone overboard," Richer wrote.
Another potential legal path could depend on the incumbent senator, who could try to argue that the Democrats carried out a deliberately deceptive scheme that confused voters and impacted the outcome. Sullivan has not conceded the race and has said he would wait for all the votes to be counted and the race to be certified next week before he decides how to proceed.
But Derek Muller, a professor of law at the University of Notre Dame, argued that a Sullivan legal challenge would be a long shot, especially since Peltola got more than 50% of the vote.
Votebeat Brunch: A rebound in voter confidence in elections
November’s surprising election also produced another unexpected outcome: A spike in voter confidence in the results. A new University of California San Diego survey found that 66% of Americans believe the November midterm elections were free and fair, up from 49% who thought they would be in September, when they last asked the question.
But the number masks a notable partisan divide. Democratic confidence in the results, which produced a massive blue wave, rose from 63% in September to 92% this month. Confidence among independents jumped from 49% to 69%. But Republican confidence ticked down from 58% to 52%.
Votebeat spoke to Thad Kousser and Lauren Prather, co-directors of the university’s Center for Transparent and Trusted Elections, about the results.
What were your most important takeaways from the survey?
Kousser: This poll showed two things. That there has been this really strong rebound in trust in elections after an election that was decisive, that was followed by quick concession speeches, and then had very few administrative problems. So trust in that the election was free and fair goes from 49 to 66%. That's a big move from less than a majority to a supermajority. Democrats and independents are at really high levels, about as high as you ever see in their trust in the vote count nationwide.
But we do have this reemergence of a partisan divide where Republicans — understandably; this is the group that lost a decisive election — actually went down [a] small bit in both of those measures. Trust is still much much higher among Republicans than it was in the wake of 2020, or even in the wake of the 2022 midterms. So everybody's at a higher base, but there is that partisan divide. And so I think what we're seeing is this is a time that's kind of given election officials breathing room, while they still have work to do to bring all parties along in having an earned trust of elections.
Is this just an example of the so-called “winner-loser” effect where confidence goes up among those whose side wins and goes down among the side that loses?
Prather: One of the things that our survey reveals is what happens in between these elections. What you can see is a decline over time. So, much of the loss in trust among Republicans happened in the intervening years, not as a result of the election itself. So if you just looked at where Republican trust was post-2024 and then looked at it post-2026, you'd see this huge, massive decline. Most of that decline happened across January and then January to September, and really we only see a 6-percentage-point decline in trust from September to November. So that suggests to us there's something going on that's different.
Does the Democratic rise in confidence from 63% to 92% in two months seem to be a reflection of the “winner-loser” effect?
Prather: There were a lot of concerns and a lot of effects on confidence about federal interference in elections leading up to the midterms. In our previous survey, we found more than a third of Democrats and independents expected ICE to be at the polls. They said that ICE at the polls would cause them to lose confidence in elections. Republicans said they would actually feel more reassured if ICE were at the polls. …
On Election Day, we didn't see any of those things really that the Democrats and independents were really concerned about. So I think partially these huge gains are an emotional reaction to winning, but also these expectations that there was going to be significant interference or significant presence of ICE or other folks trying to influence the election that just didn't pan out.
Do you have a sense that election denialism fever may be breaking among some voters?
Prather: What we know from research on misinformation is people tend to remember the first thing that they hear. So we always tell election officials to get out there with the facts early, because some of our research has shown that if you give people the facts and then they hear the misinformation about elections, the facts tend to stick with them, and there's not as big of an effect of misinformation.
And I'm almost wondering if this is functioning similarly. The fact that it was so clear on election night that many of the losing candidates and the leader of the party that lost the election came out and said they were going to accept it. That it's just hard now to cut through those initial statements and claim that the election was rigged. So that's one potential reason for why it's maybe not as effective.
New From Votebeat
From Votebeat National: Despite Democrats’ big win, mid-decade redistricting still benefited Republicans in the 2026 election
From Votebeat National: Votebeat’s Expert Desk helped hundreds of journalists cover the midterms. It’s still open.
From Votebeat Wisconsin: Wisconsin students again face long lines to vote as officials grapple with campus wait times
From Votebeat Michigan: The Michigan Voting Rights Act could finally become law in 2027. Here’s everything you need to know.
From Votebeat Arizona: Secretary of State Adrian Fontes pitches big changes to Arizona voting laws ahead of 2028
From Votebeat Pennsylvania: In a rarity, petitioners in every precinct of Pennsylvania’s 41st House District have requested a recount
In Other Voting News
Caucus urges Legislature to investigate secretary of state over voters wrongly inactivated: ‘He’s shuffling accountability’, Mississippi Today
Broad satisfaction with 2026 midterm election administration, Pew Research Center
Alaska voters reject ballot measure seeking to repeal open primaries and ranked voting system, Associated Press
Meet the 27-year-old Jackson native behind Scott Colom’s viral ‘pick another protein’ campaign ad, Mississippi Today
Has election denialism run its course?, Dispatch
She won a Texas House seat. Her rival says she can’t take office, New York Times
Tennessee Gov.-elect Marsha Blackburn expected to prioritize closing of primaries, Tennessee Lookout
After election gains, North Carolina Democrats and advocates push for voting rights, redistricting reforms, NC Newsline
How voting rights impacted the 2026 midterms, Time (Opinion)
Looking for your next read? Check out these other great newsletters.


